Collection

The members of the board of trustees of a pension fund must draw up the investment strategy and organise and supervise its implementation. If they fail to do so, in particular if they conclude a discretionary mandate without any investment strategy and without supervising the investment manager, the members will incur civil liability (9C_496/2022, 9C_503/2022, 9C_504/2022, 9C_505/2022). A pension fund for a nursing home in Fribourg decided to enter into a discretionary management contract with an asset management company. The[...]

There is nothing new about the fact that an asset manager who engages in churning is liable to a criminal conviction (disloyal management - art. 158 of the Swiss Criminal Code). In its ruling 6B_1118/2023 of 26 April 2024, the Swiss Federal Supreme Court analysed in detail the evidence that would allow a churning activity to be identified or ruled out, i.e. carrying out a large number of transactions with the sole aim of increasing retrocessions. Between 2003 and 2005,[...]

FINMA has published a draft of a new circular entitled "Rules of Conduct under the Investment Services Financing Act and the Investment Services Financing Ordinance". The aim of the draft is to enhance legal certainty two years after the end of the transitional period following the entry into force of these standards and the first prudential audit cycle on this subject. Overall, it is a relatively modest project. Rather than extending the scope or providing a general commentary, it is[...]

An asset manager who does not comply with the conservative investment strategy agreed with his client is not in breach of his contractual obligations if the client has validly approved the investments (Federal Court ruling 4A_507/2023 of 29 February 2024). In this judgment, the client consults an asset manager to manage part of his assets. Over the years, the client entered into three different management relationships with the service provider. In the third relationship, which gave rise to the dispute,[...]